Cracked Tiles

Hi

My neighbour's contractor came by to 'Make Good' the cracked tiles his renovation caused.

As they hacked one tile, another cracked. The worker was not alert enough to notify his supervisor that the replacement tiles were different from Tile "A".

As there are insufficient tiles, they could not replace with Tile "B".

What options do I have?

I loved my kitchen the way it was, wasted my leave to oversee the failed 'Make Good' and now have Tiles 'A', Tiles 'B' and Tiles 'Cracked' in my kitchen.

Please be generous with your advice and give me an idea of the price.

Thanks