I started off with an excel too when I first started comparing quotes. But gave up after 5 companies. Haha. They basically jack up different areas to earn their money. There's no way we can compare apple to apple line by line. Will suggest instead to comparing them line by line, tell the companies exactly what you want (including how many fts for carpentry, full height or half height, brand of hinges to be used, what type of paint etc), and den compare the overall quote that came back. Choose those that falls within your budget, or at least not too far off (can still bargain when ready to finalise), check for feedback on forums, then meet up with those shortlisted IDs to assess the chemistry you have with them. Along the way, you may have already stuck off many IDs who were not responsive, don't bother about ur budget etc. Through this method, hubby and I ended up meeting just 6 ID firms, out of the many who quoted us from the forum quotation requests. Hope this will help ease some of the headache u face when choosing your ID!